THE SCRATCH  SHEET VOLUME #18

March 17, 2010

 

IN THIS ISSUE:

A.  JON NEWTON ’56 RETIRES FROM THE STEEL & GARNETT

B.  REUNION COMMITTEE MEETS IN FLORIDA

C.  CLASS GIFT UPDATE

D.  THOUGHTS ON THE CLASS GIFT

E.  THE REUNION COMMITTEE WEIGHS IN ON THE CLASS GIFT

F.  TOURING THE GIRARD COLLECTION: FRIDAY MAY 21, 10-           11:30 or 4-5:30

G.  JIM SWANTEK IS FOUND

H. CORINTHIAN II AND THOSE NASTY PROFILES:  A REPORT FROM THE COMMUNICATIONS COMMITTEE

I.  SOME OTHER THINGS

 

CONTACTS FOR THIS ISSUE:

 

BOB CULVER:  973-628-0786; fabo2@verizon.net 

ROCCO D’AMICO:  301-229-0834; rdamico@ihsm.com

ED DIROMALDO: 215-365-5965; pomodon@comcast.net

JOE FRIGIOLA:  609-702-0503; joefrigiola@comcast.net

JOHN KANE:  215-343-5769; jjkgc60@verizon.net

 

 

A.   JON NEWTON ’56 RETIRES FROM THE STEEL & GARNETT

 

Most of you have recently received the Winter 2010 edition of the Steel & Garnet, the Alumni Association’s quarterly magazine.  In that issue Jon Newton announces his retirement from the position of Editor of the magazine after 12 years of service.  During that time Jon has been responsible for two issues a year.  (We believe the Alumni office has been responsible for the other two issues each year.)  Over the years we have received many favorable comments from classmates praising Newton’s work.  “Who’s this guy, stirring the shit.”   Jon has pissed off a bunch of people during his tenure, but your editor has always felt that his “stirring” has been extremely useful (and entertaining.)  It’s always great to have a gadfly who makes sense.  Not surprisingly his final issue is a tour de force, which you need to pull out of the pile of eventual discards and read cover to cover. (If you find a few Scratch Sheets in that pile, read them also.) 

 

In it you will find:

 

  • An interview with Jon with the questions posed by Jon, recapitulating his years in the position, pp2, 33, and 35.  Jon takes on his friends, enemies, and those in the middle in this piece.
  • A piece on the installation of Autumn Adkins as President of the Hum, pp 3-6.  Many of the items referenced in that section, but not published, are available in SS#13 dated 11/12/2009,  Girard1960.com, including Pete Shoemaker’s introduction of the new president, the articles/interviews with Ms. Adkins in the Inquirer, and Philadelphia Magazine, and Ms. Adkins acceptance speech.
  • A letter from Gil Bunker ’53, the Hum’s volunteer archivist, on the derivation of the words, Hum and Hummer.  (p. 7)  Mr. Bunker is currently supporting our efforts on Corinthian II  in helping us to find photos for inclusion. 
  • A letter from Tom DiFillippo ’44 objecting to some of President Adkins thoughts in the Inquirer interview, along with Ms. Atkins response.  (p. 8).  Newton adds his two cents on p. 35.  The issue is the desegregation of the Hum, both racially and genderly, and gets to a number of issues that have been discussed in our process of planning our 50th reunion.
  • A piece on Pete Shoemaker’s ascension to the Chairmanship of the Hum’s Board of Managers. (p. 9).  Newton gets a little snarky there.  So we know one classmate who’s happy to see him go.  Just kidding Pete.
  • The conclusion of Newton’s series on Hummers’ participation in America’s wars, this time Vietnam.  John Houghton’s remembrances in an earlier Scratch Sheet are included, along with some wrenching material to which we didn’t have access.  Also mentioned in the article are Chuck Killen, Judd Johnson, and Dennis Gries.
  • Two articles dealing with Stephen Girard’s life and reputation.  One on the Toussaint Louverture affair, where Girard was accused of stealing the Haitian rebellion leaders’ funds p.28, and another on Girard’s treatment of his mentally ill wife, Mary, p.30.

 

So guys, get into those piles, and dig it out, and read it cover to cover.  Your editor will miss Newton, and if you feel the same you can express your thanks to him at jonvnewton@gmail.com.  One question: remember “Peanut” Schoell; did John’s classmates call him “Fig” Newton”?

 

B.  REUNION COMMITTEE MEETS IN FLORIDA

 

Attendees:  Baji, Caplan, D’Amico, Evans, Frigiola, Gries, Kane, Mills, Phillips,

Shoemaker

 

Once again, Pete & Roz Shoemaker were the perfect hosts.  This was our third

Winter meeting at their home in Tampa.  Liz Baji, Anna Evans, Linda O’Hara,

Judy Gries, Roz Shoemaker, and Shawn Mills were also in attendance and were helpful

in contributing their ideas.

 

Along with dinner together Friday night, the golfers in the group spend Saturday morning lying to each other about their skills.  We hear Toby had a miracle round.  The non-golfers headed off to Indian Rocks Beach for the now almost traditional lunch at Crabby Bill’s, and another tour of the South Florida Botanical Gardens.  Then it was dinner at Pete’s and the meeting which is recounted below.

 

We now have 52 returns from Survey 3.  The Class Dinner, Chapel Services, and Saturday lunch will draw the highest attendance with 45 classmates signed up for each.  The number of additional guests for these events ranges from 33 to 65.  We still have not heard from 9 guys whose attendance we have estimated to be ‘highly probable’, and another 19 ‘needing encouragement’, so these numbers are sure to increase.  .

 

We’re still undecided as to whether we should move the class dinner from the Library to Founder’s Hall because of our numbers.  The decision must be made by May 1st.  Also since the numbers indicate that we may have as many as 70 people at the Hospitality Suite at some points, we need to ensure that we will have adequate space.  Frigiola and Kane will revisit the Hotel to take a closer look at the rooms we have reserved. 

 

Fund raising for the Class Gift and Administrative costs is going well.  So far, we stand at approximately $167K toward our $200K goal.  Of this amount $7500 has been designated for the Admin Fund, and $1700 for the Help Fund.

 

We also reviewed all anticipated expense items in order to establish a budget for the admin charges.  The biggest items are the meals (i.e., the Class Dinner, Saturday Lunch, and Sunday Brunch).  Also included with these are beverage and refreshment costs for the Hospitality Suites, the Dance, and the cocktail hour.  After these are video editing for the DVD take away, potential AV charges from the Hum, and the production costs of Corinthian II.  It seems we are pretty much on track, but still need to be mindful of what we are spending.  It was suggested that we might charge for alcoholic beverages at the Class Dinner – say $2/drink.  It remains a possibility.

 

We discussed options for the dinner favor.  The current front runner is a combination paper weight/ magnifying glass.  However, we questioned the necessity for any favor at all.  We may eliminate this expense altogether.

 

On the subject of the Class Gift we noted that 8 options have been identified so far.  (See SS#17).  We decided that we should consider something in President Adkins’ expressed vision for the school that could be attributed to our class.  Pete will arrange a second visit  with Autumn to identify specifics.  Following that , a subcommittee of Shoemaker, Caplan, Evans, and Frigiola will make a recommendation.  At the end of the Scratch Sheet are photos of the “beautiful people” in attendance.

 

Class speaker nominations stand at three.  Selection will be made at the next meeting.

We  reaffirmed our preference for having honorary diplomas granted to non-graduated classmates at the chapel service.

 

The hum tours were discussed.  It was decided to keep the Friday tours (Stephen Girard collection) at 10am and 4pm.  We now need to identify the particular people interested at each time.  A plan for the Saturday afternoon Building and Tunnels tour(s) was recently promoted by Pete.  It was met with enthusiastic support by the Hum staff.  The itinerary will include stops at one of the upper halls, Junior School, the new “West End” and the power station and tunnels.  Rather than having one large group (we estimate about 80 people will participate) four groups will start simultaneously at each location then rotate through all four stops.  Bruce Seaman has agreed to coordinate this plan by visiting the school, selecting points of interest, and briefing the volunteer tour guides.

 

The fact that the Crown Plaza is a non-smoking facility was discussed.  The committee’s position was that want you do in your own rooms is between you and the hotel.  But that the hospitality room would be non-smoking.  They’ll be crowded, and we don’t need to hassle with the hotel.

 

The plan for Corinthian II was briefly discussed.  It was noted that Bob Kutchera’s piece in SS #17 was very well received.  It is exactly the self-authored profile approach that would make Corinthian II most appealing to classmates and other readers.  We should all follow suit and send Rocco our own profiles.

Written by Joe Frigiola.

 

C.  CLASS GIFT UPDATE

44 Classmates and Climbing

We now have contributions from 6 additional classmates.  The newest additions to the list are Bob Consavage, Harold Cohrs, Charlie Ellis, Frank Rieg, Bruce Seaman and John Tait.  Thank you, guys.

$157,000 and Climbing

We now have approximately $157,000 and commitments for an additional $12,000.  Here is the summary, by category:

$15,000 and above_____________________________________________________________________       

Toby Caplan

Don Ratajczak

Pete Shoemaker

$10,000 and above_____________________________________________________________________                        

Rich Adams

Rocco D’Amico

Joe Frigiola

Rich Page

$5,000 - 9,999_________________________________________________________________________

Bruce Singer

$2,500 – 4,999_________________________________________________________________________

Dennis Bevans

Bob Culver

Dennis Gries

John Myers

$1,000 – 2,499_________________________________________________________________________

Anonymous

Joe Baji

Harold Cohrs

Ed DiRomaldo

Bill Evans

John Gearhart

Ed Hill

John Kane

Matt Mills

Nelson Mishkin

Dave Phillips

Rich Popella

Frank Rieg

Dave Ross

Ron Saracini

$500 – 999____________________________________________________________________________

Art Garfein

Leland Giannini

Byron Orrs

Bruce Seaman

John Tait

$1 – 499______________________________________________________________________________

Joe Alberici

Al Bullock

Bob Consavage

Charlie Ellis

Dan Ferro

John Hagerty

John Houghton

Garry Jakoby

Ed Koch

Mike Quinn

Carl Sehl

John Woods

 

Memorials
Ron Barath                  Kane, Kathy (John)

Ed Coccagna               Dave Paulson

Sterling Gedraitis        Paul Register

Walt Grey                   Jim Ritchie

Bob Himmelrich          Carl Sehl        

John Heaney               Jim Stidham

Judd Johnson

 

That’s the good news.  However, we still have a way to go to hit both our objectives.  We’re coming down the home stretch and we want to hear from all of you.  Our mantra will not change.  If you’ve already given, thank you, but please consider giving more.  Here’s how you can do it. Why not give another gift in memory of one of our classmates who is no longer with us.  Specifically, we do not have a gift in the memory of the following classmates:

 

Rich Collins                Ed Mitchell

Bob Corrigan              Jim Rule

Joe Diorio                    Mario Rullo

Bob Kelly                    Manny Sheitelman

Bob Killen                   Bob Siren

 

If you plan to give, please give NOW.  If you don’t plan to give, please reconsider.  Girard and your classmates need your support.  We need $31,000 more to hit our goal of $200,000 and we still have not heard from approximately 40 classmates.  We’ve already established the reputation of being a stellar class.  We are the talk and envy of the Alumni Association.  Let’s really give them something to talk about.  CAN WE COUNT ON YOU?

 

Checks can be sent to Myron Caplan, 110 Deangelo Drive, Pittsburgh, PA 15209.  Checks should be made out to GCAA, with Class of ’60 Gift written into the Memo line.

 

Thanks for your support.

Toby and Peter

 

D.  THOUGHTS ON THE CLASS GIFT

 

In response to the eight gift recommendations which were detailed in SS#17 we received the following 5 responses:

 

1,  Thinking about the Gift and the recommendations. I kind of like the Capital Campaign, GCAA, Pete's "French Connection," and the idea for bricks for all the classmates.

2. While I greatly appreciate Pete Shoemaker's generosity in providing an international  experience to current Girard students, I believe that is his endowment and not that of the class.  I really would prefer something that is easily identified as the class's gift and not an addition to an existing endowment.

3.  I would vote for something tangible that mentions our Class –that is of ongoing use to the students.  I don’t think bricks have any real impact and Pete has already left his legacy with his and Roz’ generous donation.  Maybe an annual lectureship on Race in America?  I don’t think the current students are in a “cocoon’ the way it seemed to us at times.  They may have “too much’ contact in the wider world at times.  I think our gift should be separate from Pres. Adkins “Vision” which will be open to all alumni to support.

4. Class Gift--I think that maintaining Pete and Roz Shoemaker's gift for kids to experience international travel is a real opportunity that may never again present itself.  Money should be set aside to sustain this project, and reinforce the concept that we are all citizens of the world.

5. I believe:

One shot deals should not be included;

The parties idea is not productive;

Supporting counseling is a good idea;

That we should provide some money for the alumni association;

That we shouldn’t provide money for the development fund.  That’s the responsibility of all Alumni.

That we might consider funding a lounge area/meeting room in the library, and support efforts to bring in experts to speak in-depth on career choices.

 

There is still time to give your opinions.  Review the 8 ideas presented in SS#17, and those directly stated or implied above.  Get any thoughts you have to Joe Frigiola, (see Contacts list above.)  It’s your contribution, so get involved.

 

E.  THE REUNION COMMITTEE WEIGHS IN ON THE CLASS GIFT

 

As we planned the reunion we were conscious of a number of factors. We wanted to establish many events during the 3 ˝ day period as possible in different types of venues to give classmates many opportunities to meet and get reacquainted.  We also wanted to keep the costs down so that everyone could participate.  One approach which was developed to meet both of these goals was the administrative fund.  In a meeting early last year Rich Adams suggested that the Class Dinner on Friday night should be free to each classmate and one guest, and provided $2500 for those purposes.  Since then many other classmates have followed Rich, and the class gift administrative fund has gone up to around $7000.  Along with the Class Dinner, the fund is there to cover all costs associated with increasing the Class Gift including costs of the various committees, printing and mailing of the Scratch Sheet, printing of Corinthian II, the costs of various DVDs, and CDs to be distributed at the reunion, services provided by the Hum and other service providers who support our efforts.

 

In December last year we sent out Survey 3 listing all the planned events of the weekend with the associated individual costs for classmates to attend each event.  In that mailing we estimated the costs of the Saturday lunch in the D&S at $7, and the Sunday Brunch in the D&S as around $10.  Both were open to any number of classmates and guests.  In response we got reservations for the Lunch of 110 classmates and guests, and 48 for the Brunch.  In the following reunion committee meetings we were attempting to plan on how the charges for these two events could be collected.  The committee decided that almost all proposed approaches presented a logistical nightmare.  Consequently, it was decided that we should make these events free and pay for them out of the administrative fund.  First, the numbers were only half developed as to how many people planned to participate in these events, and second we felt that these would encourage those who are living on fixed budgets to attend.  The downside was that the residual of the administrative fund would go into the Class Gift, and would not be available for those purposes. 

 

The true costs for the two meals are now known.  They are a little higher than expected, on average of about $13 for each meal served.  A number of committee members volunteered to pay the costs for themselves and their guests for these meals.  Upon reflection we have decided to suggest the following.  Anyone who can afford it should calculate the costs of bringing themselves and their guests to these meals, and make an equivalent contribute to the Class Gift to offset these costs.  This is of course a totally voluntary contribution and should be handled as described above in Section B and designated as a part of the Class Gift.   If you can’t afford to do it, we understand.

 

F.  TOURING THE GIRARD COLLECTION FRIDAY MAY 21, 10-11:30 or 4-5:30

 

One of Philadelphia’s most distinctive historical collections – the Stephen Girard Collection – is preserved on the 43-acre Girard College campus.  The household furnishings, used by the school’s founder, are displayed within Founder’s Hall – the school’s magnificent central building, modeled after a Greek temple.

 

The Stephen Girard Collection is among America’s most important collections of decorative and fine arts from the early national period, 1780 – 1830.  The collection includes the partial contents of Girard’s Philadelphia townhouse – furniture, ceramics, silver, textiles, paintings and prints made in Philadelphia, England, France and China.  Surviving original bills for many objects document the work of city craftsmen Daniel Trotter, Ephraim Haines, Henry Connelly, Joseph Richardson and many others.  The collection combines plain items with sophisticated imported objects, suggesting the complex tastes and lifestyle of this little-known Philadelphian.  The Stephen Girard Collection combines authentic objects of impeccable provenance, displayed at the school founded by its owner.  Come see the fascinating history of early Philadelphia in an unforgettable setting.

 

The tours will be conducted by Elizabeth Laurent, the Director of Historic Resources at Girard College and the co-author of Girard College – a Living History (2009).  She is a graduate of Williams College, the Winterthur Program in Early American Culture at the University of Delaware and the Attingham Summer School.  She was formerly the Curator at Cliveden of the National Trust in Philadelphia, and Stratford Hall Plantation in Virginia.  Ms. Laurent has been a curatorial consultant for the Grundy Fundation, Friends of Lemon Hill Mansion, Stenton, the Pennsylvania Sons of the Revolution, Loudoun and Historic RittenhouseTown.  She is a Trustee of the Philadelphia History Museum.

 

We will start at the Girard sarcophagus in the front hall of Founder's Hall, and proceed to the first-floor Board Room focusing on the remarkable George Gibbes murals for an orientation to Girard's life.  The group will ascend up the 48 (!) steps to the second floor museum, including the two large rooms filled with the nationally significant household artifacts of Stephen Girard's Philadelphia townhouse.  We will conclude in the two smaller rooms filled with the Girardiana Collection that tells the story of student life on the Girard campus.  There will be opportunity to ask lots of questions, and to purchase books, cd's and postcards available only at Founder's Hall.

 

Note on the steps.  Yes, that’s 48 between floors.  For those who haven’t been to Founders recently, those steps are not the rutted marble they were in our day.  They have been repaired, but it’s still a haul for our old bones.

 

G.  JIM SWANTEK IS FOUND

 

Last week at our reunion meeting (to be reported on in the next Scratch Sheet), it was decided that we would abandon our efforts to reach out to those classmates who have remained silent through all of attempts to reach them.  Yesterday, Joe Frigiola received a call from one of them, Jim Swantek.  Jim must have ESP.  Jim indicated he plans to come to a number of the reunion events.  Great!

 

You all remember Jim as one of the quietest members of our class.  Our Corinthian noted: “Swan is quiet but not withdrawn.  He has a friendly nature and facility for comradeship.  He expresses his conscientiousness in whatever he does and particularly in the Concert Band and Glee Club.”   Jim served in Vietnam and was wounded twice resulting in him being blind in one eye, deaf in one ear, and sustaining a broken jaw, nose, and elbow.  He spent his career after that in the printing business.  He has two children, and four grandchildren.  He says he mostly spends his time in backyard gardening.

 

H. CORINTHIAN II AND THOSE NASTY PROFILES:  A REPORT FROM THE COMMUNICATIONS COMMITTEE

 

The communications committee, Bob Culver, Rocco D’Amico, Ed DiRomaldo, John Few and Dennis Gries, is working hard, but slowly losing its collective mind.  Along with getting out Scratch Sheets, tracking down families of the deceased so that they know what we’re doing, catalogueing photos, developing CDs and DVDs as keepsakes to be distributed at the reunion, we are also trying to put together a publication, Corinthian II, also to be distributed at the reunion.

 

So here’s the deal.  Corinthian II is visualized as a printed and bound hard copy document reflecting our lives in the Hum and beyond, along with profiles of each person who was at sometime a member of the Class of ’60.   It will have two major sections plus an addendum.  The first section will be a chronology of our lives, year by year.  We’ll start at West End and move to Allen Hall with a few subsidiary sections which are not chronology related, i.e. the Chapel, the library, health care in the Hum, etc.  The second section, The Profiles, will be a collection of individual portraits of all of our classmates: their feelings about their experiences in the Hum and its’ impact on their lives, recollections of what happened to them after June 16, 1960, education, jobs, marriages, children and beyond, what they are doing now, the pills they take, and the body joints that ache (please not too much of that).  The addendum will include many photos, and miscellaneous items that bring us back to our existence 50-60 years ago.

 

Right now our major undertaking is the Profiles.  There are three classes.  One, those we receive from all of you who have been participating in our communications over the years.  Two, those about our living classmates who have chosen to ignore us, and are unlikely to send us any materials.  Three, profiles on our classmates who have passed away.    Dennis and Rocco have the ball on the third group, and will have to rely on 50 years of newsletters to reconstruct profiles of the departed.  This may involve some contact with family members of our classmates, and also information that all of you can provide.  We will contact you if we feel you might have some information which would help in constructing these profiles.  We have attached one such profile to this Scratch Sheet, John Heaney’s.  You will note in the last paragraph that Rocco added a personal note about John.  You’ll will help us get ahead of the game, if you have any thoughts on one or more of the deceased classmates, and can forward them to Rocco for inclusion in those classmates’ profiles.

 

With the non-responders we will do the best we can, and contact individual classmates where we suspect that they may have information which would be of value.  If you have info or thoughts on any of these classmates, please feel free to send it along to Rocco.

 

Finally, we get to all of you who have been in touch over the years.  At this point we have most of the information we need on about 20 of you.  But the rest of you are still sitting on your hands.  If we don’t get some help from you, we are not going to be able to finish Corinthian II in time to have it available for you on the reunion weekend.  Here’s what we need guys:

 

  • A text, hopefully in Word, which tells us whatever you would like included in your profile.  You can concentrate on your life after the Hum, or include material on life in the Hum, or even before.  You can write it in the first or third person, whatever you’re comfortable with.  Handwritten is also OK.  Or if you would like you can dictate it to Rocco.
  • Photos.  We would like one shot of you from which we can extract a headshot.  Bob Culver can do this from almost any photo be it digital, or hard copy, as long as your head is not too small in the photo.  This photo will appear close to the photo of you taken from Corinthian I.  Then any photos you would like added at the bottom of the text, for example, you with your spouse, and/or kids, your Great Dane, or whatever else you would like.  Hopefully all the shots, including the head shot, will be of relatively recent vintage.
  • You can send the material described above to either Bob or Rocco.  If you are sending hard copy photos they should go to Bob.  He will return them to you once he has digitized them.

 

We have attached three additional profiles to this Scratch Sheet as examples, Bertino, Fiore, and Phillips.  You should feel free to choose your own ideas.  Certainly these three concentrate on “after Hum” events, but you should not feel constrained to restrict yourself to that aspect of your life alone.  The next Scratch Sheet, coming out shortly, will have more examples for your perusal.  But please guys, take the two or three hours which will be necessary to get your material in ASAP.

 

And, by the way, Ed DiRomaldo is pulling his end by continuing to collect and catalogue photos to fill out the other sections of Corinthian II.  He is well over 400 photos all of which will be put together on a CD for you to take away from our reunion weekend.  So please get those photos of our lives in the Hum to Ed.

 

I.  SOME OTHER THINGS

 

  1. Memorabilia.  We received in a plain brown paper package a photo album.  It included 92 unique postcards depicting Founders Hall.  Most are from the early 1900s, even then they are in mint condition.  The sender? John (Herm) Woods.  John and his wife, Mildred, are collectors of salt and pepper shakers, and frequent flea markets, and antique shows in their pursuit.  John always takes the time to go to the “postcard” table to seek out Founders Hall postcards.  (Well, they’re not photos of babes in bikinis, but they do show the days when Founders was a world wide tourist attraction.)  Ed DiRomaldo will be setting up displays of both John’s postcards, and Rich Page’s memorabilia so that they can be viewed at the two dinners on reunion weekend.  John and Rich have both agreed to gift their collections to the Hum historical office after the weekend.

 

We also received a treasure trove from John Tait.  He sent us a complete collection of The Girard News from our Senior Year.   We hope to include them in Corinthian II.  John also sent the first two years of the Michaluk Scratch Sheets, which means we have now collected all the newsletters of the last fifty years.  John Few is indexing these latest and all the 20th century communications will soon be on the website.

     

     2.    Hotel.  There is only one of the original block of rooms available from the hotel.  The hotel will      

provide rooms at the negotiated rate beyond that one until April 15, assuming there are still rooms available.  So if you’re coming and need a room, don’t dwaddle.  Call John Kane for help.

 

     3.    Name Tags.  Bob Culver has produced name tags for all classmates who have indicated they are                         

coming, along with their spouses or significant others.  However, if your wife’s name is not listed on the Class List no name tag has been produced.  So if your wife’s name is not on the Class List  let Bob know, and he will get it done.

 

4.        Photo from Florida Committee Meeting is on the next page.

 

One of  Herm’s postcards.

 




The boys, from 6 o’clock, clockwise:  Phillips, Damico, Evans, Mills, Frigiola, Kane, Caplan, Gries, Showmaker, Baji

The Girls: Linda O’Hara, Karlyn Phillips, Elizabeth Baji, Judy Gries, Shawn Mills, Anna Evans, Roz Shoemaker